Introduction: Revolutionizing Investment Analysis with AI
The article discusses how professionals at Hubbard Decision Research use large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, to accelerate the creation of Monte Carlo simulations and dynamic financial models in Excel. While LLMs are still prone to errors similar to human mistakes, their ability to break down complex problems into logical components makes them valuable tools for initiating investment analyses.
Background: Current Modeling Challenges
Monte Carlo simulations are critical for analyzing investment scenarios but often demand significant time—ranging from 30 minutes to several hours—depending on the problem’s complexity. This process involves breaking down variables, assigning probabilities, and generating thousands of simulations. Although human effort remains essential for accuracy, the workflow can be slow and susceptible to errors.
Adopting LLMs for Investment Projections
The author explored integrating LLMs like ChatGPT into quantitative risk analysis. By connecting to ChatGPT via API, investment problems were described, and the LLM generated Python code to populate pre-built Excel analysis templates. For example, a hypothetical scenario involving the purchase and rental of a townhouse was tested, with the LLM successfully outlining variables and constructing initial probability distributions, such as renovation costs and rent fluctuations.
Recognizing Overconfidence in AI Predictions
While LLMs effectively simulate values for variables, the article highlights their tendency to offer overconfident predictions. Calibration efforts—such as widening confidence intervals when necessary—help mitigate this issue, enhancing the reliability of AI-driven analyses. These adjustments ensure more accurate probability distributions and improved model realism.
Challenges: Human-Like Errors Detected
During testing, the accuracy of AI models revealed a critical limitation: LLMs often replicate human-like errors in calculations. For example, incorrect management fee formulas or misunderstandings about variable relationships were identified during manual audits. This reinforces the need for human oversight when engaging LLMs for financial modeling.
Efficiency: Viewing AI as “Fast Interns”
Despite their limitations, LLMs offer significant productivity gains, akin to “very fast but error-prone interns.” These tools reduce the time spent on repetitive tasks, enabling analysts to focus on higher-order insights. The models are particularly effective as a starting point for problem decomposition and initial simulation generation, although careful review is essential to avoid costly mistakes.
Looking Ahead: Improved Accuracy on the Horizon
The article concludes optimistically about the growing capabilities of LLMs. As AI technology matures, its potential for generating more accurate and comprehensive models will increase. However, collaboration between human expertise and machine efficiency will remain central to ensuring high-quality financial analyses.
Resource
Read more in Using LLMs to Generate Models in Excel
